[About Us][Affordable Housing Bulletin][CLTs][Co ops][Day for Housing][Fair Housing][HANDS!][Housing in a Hurry][Housing Journal][Join Us!]
[Landlord Tenant Code][Links to Friends][Living Wages][Manufactured Housing][Plans][Publications][Realities of Poverty][Tenants Rights][Search]
 

 

 


THE CHALLENGE OF THE NEEDS ASSESSMENT
To the Governor's Council on Housing
Ken Smith
Fall 2003

 

dhc@housingforall.org

Last Spring, a group of 18 nonprofit housing developers and advocates, shared among themselves their concerns about the growing problem of financing affordable housing in Delaware. In addition to DHC, they included Appoquinimink Development Corporation, Arc of Delaware, Better Homes of Seaford, Delaware Rural Housing Consortium, Delmarva Rural Ministries, First State Community Action Agency, First State Resource Conservation and Development Council (Emergency Home Repair Program), Interfaith Housing Delaware, Interfaith Mission of Sussex County, Latin American Community Center Development Corporation, Milford Housing Development Corporation, Millsboro Housing for Progress, National Alliance for the Mentally Ill in Delaware, NCALL Research, Neighborhood House, Westend Neighborhood House, and YWCA of New Castle County. This article is a reflection on and a report of those common concerns.

Amassing resources to fund affordable housing is a major and consuming part of the job of nonprofits. This is even more the case when they are attempting to meet the housing needs of the most vulnerable among Delaware’s citizens or to make use of housing to renew blighted areas.

Delaware Housing Needs

The newly released Delaware State-Wide Housing Needs Assessment: 2003 - 2007 (Mullin & Lonergan Associates, Inc., Pittsburgh, PA), which the Delaware State Housing Authority (DSHA) commissioned, graphically illustrates the demand for rental housing for the poorest among us. The study finds that, "Over the next five years, 2,985 units are needed either through new construction or the substantial rehabilitation of vacant dilapidated buildings: an average of approximately 600 units a year." Of this total, 1,835 units are needed for extremely low-income households, below 30% of area median income (AMI). Another 575 are needed for very-low income households, whose income falls below 50% of AMI (but above 30% of AMI). This constitutes 2,410 households (81%) of the 2,985 households in need of new housing units for the next five years. Put another way, households below 50% of AMI in Delaware require 482 new units annually (out of 600).

Housing Development Fund

It is necessary to reevaluate the current use of the HDF for two reasons. First of all, in light of the level or reduced funding which the Housing Development Fund (HDF) has received over the past few years, and the overwhelming use of these funds to lend viability to tax credit projects, the HDF has little available for creative homeownership and deep-subsidy rental projects and for other special uses. Secondly, the current use of the HDF serves the group of renters targeted by the tax credit program, which is typically between 50% to 60% of area median income (AMI). While some households below 50% of AMI access tax credit units through the assumption of greater rent burdens, this is not the purpose of the program, and it will not make a significant contribution to the daunting number of units required to serve the very-poor and extremely poor. Continued use of the HDF primarily to make tax credit projects viable will not allow it to help DSHA meet the major challenge of housing the poor.

The enabling Delaware legislation for the HDF includes the following injunction [4030 (c)(2)(e)]:

In allocating the resources of the Housing Development Fund over time, any program mix or targeting of funds shall account for the demographics of the population in need of housing, should balance the programs appropriately between rental assistance and ownership, and should apportion the available resources statewide according to local need.

The members of the Governor’s Council on Housing must take this charge into serious consideration. Given the current set of housing needs in Delaware, this will lead to a reexamination of the existing use of the HDF. It may require DSHA to forego the use of some of the tax credit allocation available to it annually, until such time as more resources are available to meet both the needs of conventional tax credit projects and other vital needs. Many creative projects have been funded by the HDF in the past, both with and without the use of tax credits. Strategic use of the HDF is more necessary than ever. We would also like to express our interest in working with you to find ways to expand the resources available to the HDF.

Council on Housing

In the light of the austere financial environment and the new needs assessment’s identification of problems which the nonprofits had suspected of being there, the members of the Council on Housing should reflect on its role as a group which can evaluate and prioritize needs, examine policy options, and use its powers to hold hearings and investigations. At the least, this seems a very opportune time for the Council to engage in some strategic planning for the prioritization of HDF use.

The new needs assessment has borne out the real world observations of community-based housing organizations on the matter of the lack of housing for the most needy Delawareans. How will this gap of almost 500 units annually be addressed? How much will it cost to meet the full need as laid out in the Needs Assessment? Can the state find resources to increase the HDF? And what impact can the nonprofit sector have in supplying and preserving units without an important reordering of the use of our limited housing resources?

 

 

Rental Needs

Households at risk: 18,150 renter households earn less than $20,000 annual income and pay more than 30% of their income toward housing expenses. These precarious socioeconomic conditions place households at risk of being one paycheck away from homelessness.

There is a need for additional rental units either to accommodate new household growth or to relieve the conditions of "at risk" renter households who are cost burdened and residing in overcrowded and/or substandard units. Over the next five years, 2,985 rental units are needed either through new construction or the substantial rehabilitation of vacant dilapidated buildings: an average of 600 units a year. The overwhelming majority of this demand is from Delawareans with very low incomes. This can be broken down by resident income levels as follows:

POPULATION IN NEED UNITS
Extremely low income (0-30% of area median) 1,835
Very low income (31-50%) 575
Low income (51-60%) 310
Other low (61-80%) 265
TOTAL DEMAND 2,985

Preservation of affordable multifamily housing: At least 5,693 rental units are in substandard condition and in need of substantial rehabilitation. This represents 6.9% of the State’s total rental inventory. In addition, 1,963 affordable rental units could be lost due to conversion to market rate housing by 2007 as a result of expiration of affordability restrictions, non-renewal of Section 8 subsidies, or an owners election to prepay a mortgage.

 

Homeownership Needs

At least 7,490 owner occupied homes are in need of substantial rehabilitation and are in substandard condition. This represents 3.5 percent of the State’s total owner occupied inventory. Substandard condition is a structure found to need two or more structural repairs in order to make the unit structurally sound, safe and habitable. Such rehabilitation is quantified as at least $30,000 per unit ($20,000 for mobile homes). A significant portion of Delaware’s population lives in homes that are at risk of major structural/livability issues.

First time homebuyers requiring DSHA assistance will total approximately 1,250 per year.

~ Delaware State-Wide Housing Needs Assessment: 2003 - 2007 (Mullin & Lonergan Associates, Inc., Pittsburgh, PA)

 Delaware Housing Coalition | www.housingforall.org